The Iron Man Award is awarded to the player who manages to play in every match throughout the year, whether it is “A” or “B” and includes both the fall and spring seasons.
| Award Recipient | Year |
|---|---|
| N/A | 2021-2022 |
| N/A | 2019-2020 |
| 2018-2019 | |
| 2017-2018 | |
| 2016-2017 | |
| 2015 | |
| 2014 | |
| Andy Vazquez Scott Strelec | 2013 |
| 2012 | |
| 2011 | |
| 2010 | |
| 2009 | |
| 2008 | |
| Andy Vazquez Ben Stokes John Rutt Mike Bunn Robert Rhubright Scott Strelec William Ehrhorn | 2007 |
| John Rutt John Scheidemann Robert Rhubright Scott Strelec | 2006 |
| Anwar Elliott John Rutt Justin Piro Larry Sweger Scott Strelec | 2005 |
| Andy Vazquez Grant Walter John Scheidemann Larry Sweger | 2004 |
| Andy Vazquez Jamie Forbes John Scheidemann | 2003 |
| John Scheidemann Larry Sweger | 2002 |
| John Scheidemann Larry Sweger | 2001 |
| Eric Jones Joe Pavuscko Larry Sweger Robert Rhubright | 2000 |
| Butch Hake Jamie Forbes Jeff Frank Jeremy Beacher Joe Clelan Larry Sweger Robert Rhubright | 1999 |
| Andy Nothnagle Ed Robinson Greg Ball Jamie Forbes Jeff Frank Jeremy Beacher Joe Clelan Larry Sweger Tom Wenger | 1998 |
| Joe Clelan Larry Sweger Sal Montagha | 1997 |
| Frank Cassidy Fred Soto Joe Clelan Robert Rhubright | 1996 |
| Ed Robinson Frank Cassidy Joe Clelan Robert Rhubright Tom Wenger | 1995 |
| Frank Cassidy Jamie Flowers Joe Clelan Robert Rhubright Russell Bucks | 1994 |
| Jamie Flowers Jeff Cook Joe Clelan Mike Walker | 1993 |
| Gary Beatty Jamie Flowers Jim Salus Joe Clelan John Murcavage | 1992 |
| Chris Spofford Craig Herring Fred Soto Gary Beatty Jamie Flowers John Terrell Todd Frankford Tony Trost | 1991 |
| Craig Herring Gary Beatty Jamie Flowers Jim Salus John Terrell Mike Bowser Robert Rhubright | 1990 |
| Gary Beatty Jeff Frank Randy Nolen Tony Trost | 1989 |
| Randy Nolen | 1988 |
